Health & Medical Mental Health

Studies to Interpret With Caution

Studies to Interpret With Caution

Empirical Evaluation of Very Large Treatment Effects of Medical Interventions


Pereira TV, Horwitz RI, Ioannidis JP
JAMA. 2012;308:1676-1684

Large Effects and Small Trials


Pereira and colleagues sought to evaluate the frequency and features of very large effects in medical research. Using the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, they examined binary outcomes with very large effects (odds ratio [OR], ≥ 5). Significant very large effects typically appeared in small trials with median number of events of 18 in first trials and 15 in subsequent trials. Of the very large effects observed in first and subsequently published trials, 90% and 98%, respectively, became smaller in meta-analyses that included other trials. The median OR declined from 11.88 to 4.20 for first trials and from 10.02 to 2.60 for subsequent trials. Pereira and colleagues concluded that most large treatment effects emerge from small studies, and when additional trials are performed, the effect sizes become much smaller. Well-validated large effects are uncommon.

Viewpoint


Case reports and case series about wonderful new approaches to treating an illness are often followed by small studies that show much promise. However, large controlled trials do not necessarily confirm the initial impressions that generated all the excitement. Pereira and colleagues recommend that most large treatment effect estimates should be interpreted with caution because many are spurious findings or may represent substantial overestimations.

Abstract

SHARE
RELATED POSTS on "Health & Medical"
Notes on Panic Attack Symptoms
Notes on Panic Attack Symptoms
How to Tell People "No" With More Confidence
How to Tell People "No" With More Confidence
Anxiety Symptom - What Are Anxiety Symptoms and How to Beat Them
Anxiety Symptom - What Are Anxiety Symptoms and How to Beat Them
Help Techniques in Counseling Teens With Low Self-Esteem
Help Techniques in Counseling Teens With Low Self-Esteem
Inexplicable Child Tantrums - Could They Be Bipolar Disorder?
Inexplicable Child Tantrums - Could They Be Bipolar Disorder?
5 Steps to Staying Mentally Sharp and Preventing Alzheimer's Disease
5 Steps to Staying Mentally Sharp and Preventing Alzheimer's Disease
Anger Management: Dealing With Frustration
Anger Management: Dealing With Frustration
What Really Is a Dependency
What Really Is a Dependency
The 5 Brainwave Frequencies
The 5 Brainwave Frequencies
The Best Drug Prevention
The Best Drug Prevention
Study Probes Suicide, Antidepressants
Study Probes Suicide, Antidepressants
Try These All Natural Strategies for Managing Panic Attacks
Try These All Natural Strategies for Managing Panic Attacks
Emotions and Logic - Strange Bedfellows?
Emotions and Logic - Strange Bedfellows?
Living With a Bipolar Wife
Living With a Bipolar Wife
Signs of Classic Autism
Signs of Classic Autism
Citalopram Ineffective in Children With Autism
Citalopram Ineffective in Children With Autism
Alcohol & Codeine
Alcohol & Codeine
Prerequisites to a Ph.D. Program in Psychology
Prerequisites to a Ph.D. Program in Psychology
Abused Children may have Hidden Head Injuries
Abused Children may have Hidden Head Injuries
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and Negative Core Beliefs (NCBs) - Identification
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and Negative Core Beliefs (NCBs) - Identification

Leave Your Reply

*